Hello Michael
I understand your arguments.
you transcribe to get the idea behind the music( hopefully) Not the phrase or whatever the heck some feeble minded musician do.
I understand that. It ’s a way of doing things.
But if Michael Brecker or Coltrane or Miles become the source for gathering knowledge for u. Then where do those guys get there knowledge ? do u really think that they transcribe others for ideas ? do u really think that ?
I mean transcription is good but it must not be the primary source for knowledge.
I don’t beleive that those guys learn phrases and r committed to memory when they perform, they work on ideas , and u must really be justifiably confident with the ideas to apply them. How can u be justifiably confident with an idea if it is not yours buddy ?
Don’t u think there is something much greater than just transcribing others. Chopping the music, the chords, the scales etc. Don’t u think that some musician like Coltrane and others of the same caliber do more than just transcribing they create things in music, they bring something new, they make things happen.
Think it like writing a dissertation some guys r more intelligent than others and will analyse and comment things and come with ideas that are profound, new and true. some others will just do some googling and copy paste the work done by others. who is the best essayist then ?
The end result may be the same but they may both get an A + but there is a great deal of difference between the two don’t u think ?
I am truly sorry for being an annoying Bart Simpson here sir, but i understand everything of Brecker playing i mean understand the idea behind the music not the music itself ( that would be too easy). I don’t know u i don’t judge but if this is route you have taken it is a difficult one.
Faithfully,
Logan


Catégories

  • Boutique (7)
  • Coups de coeur (8)
  • Live (9)
  • Pédagogie (28)
  • Transcriptions (34)
  • Web (19)


  • Concerts


  • Le 21/08/2017 : Presles en quintet le 21 aout

    Concert en quintet avec le saxophoniste invité Sébastien Jarousse. Au programme des compos, des standards en mode Bergonzi. Un saxophoniste coltranien à découvrir absolument.
    Entrée paf au choix !
    Salles des fetes de Presles, 20h30.
    Pour diner avant il est indispensable de réserver à l’auberge de Presles.


  • Le 22/08/2017 : 22 aout à Presles

    Concert Michael Cheret trio à la salle des fetes de Presles, 20H30 --->Boeuf à la fin !!
    Jazz standards : piano contrebasse et saxophone.
    Entrée paf au choix.
    Pour diner avant il est indispensable de reserver à l’auberge chez Ezio.


  • Le 23/08/2017 : 23 aout concert des stagiaires à Presles

    Concert des stagiaires + jam session ouverte à tous !
    Venez faire la fete avec les stagiaires sax et une rythmique pro. Entrée gratuite
    salle des fetes de Presles 20h30


  • Le 31/08/2017 : festival jazzaccord (Lentilly) Jim Rotondi 5tet

    Le french quintet de Jim Rotondi ! Du grand jazz à la New-yorkaise ! C’est à Lentilly , salle de la passerelle. Ici le site du festival


  • Le 04/09/2017 : Vandojam Sunset Paris le 4 sept.

    Vandojam hommage à Joe Henderson + jam session Sunset jazz club,
    Special guest au premier set : Balthazar Naturel.
    Paris, 60 rue des Lombards métro chatelet. 21h, gratuit. Come by and play !